EIFF 2014: A Most Wanted Man Review

The late Phillip Seymour Hoffman gives one of his last performances in Anton Corbijn's spy thriller.

In one of his last performances on the big screen, the late Phillip Seymour Hoffman proves to be the highlight of A Most Wanted Man, a solidly constructed but extremely dry adaptation of John Le Carre’s 2008 spy novel of the same name.

Hoffman stars as Gunther Bachmann, a tired and cynical veteran in German intelligence who is on the trail of Issa Karpov, a suspected terrorist who has arrived in Hamburg to collect his dead father’s fortune. Gunther is sure Karpov is innocent but plans to use him to trap a suspicious benefactor named Faisal Muhammad who may or may not be siphoning funds to al Qaeda.

Thrown into the mix is Rachel McAdams’ human rights lawyer Annabel who forms a very close bond with Karpov while trying to protect him but ultimately, she too becomes just another tool for Gunther to use in his attempts to bring down Faisal.

This is a film that moves in its own very slow and deliberate pace, with the majority of the drama coming from hushed conversations in darkened rooms. It is a slick and stylish affair with bags of intelligence but lacks any real sizzle. The most obvious touch point is another Le Carre adaptation: Tomas Alfredson’s excellent Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy which explored a similar world at a similarly leisurely pace but was dripping with tension throughout, something A Most Wanted Man can never really muster.

The cast across the board are strong, with Hoffman proving as compelling as ever even with a slightly wobbly German accent. He plays Gunther as a complex, world-weary spy who’s as well versed in exploiting people to get what he wants as he is swilling whiskey and chain-smoking cigarettes. Smaller roles are filled out by dependable actors like Daniel Bruhl, Robin Wright and Willem Dafoe with German actress Nina Hoss giving a nice turn as Gunther’s right-hand-woman. Rachel McAdams also impresses in a performance that feels like a slight departure from the norm for her and might just rank as one of her best to date.

A Most Wanted Man is not a bad film by any stretch – in fact it excels at virtually every technical level – but it ultimately feels like a slow burner that never really catches fire. It’s a neatly constructed and efficiently played espionage drama that displays admirable restraint but never feels like something you haven’t seen done before.