When her son Bull (Ben Gallacher) commits a serious crime, Iona (Ruth Negga) retreats back to the island where she was born and reconnects with the family who raised her. The circumstances in which she left the island mean her reappearance doesn’t sit well with everyone but she and Bull slowly start to integrate into the small community.
There’s tension with childhood best friend Elizabeth (Michelle Duncan) and a different kind of tension altogether with Daniel (Douglas Henshall), Elizabeth’s father and the man who raised Iona as a child.
This all plays out over long, awkward silences and clipped conversations as writer/director Scott Graham dripfeeds details of the characters’ pasts and the various secrets, desires and grudges that exist between them all.
Somewhere in here is a compelling melodrama and Iona, capably acted by Negga, could’ve been an intriguing character but the film’s glacial pace and relentlessly grim tone makes it impossible to engage with. It sounds like Graham’s debut film, Shell, had a similar style (I haven’t seen it) but that style suffocates the story he’s trying to tell here.
There’s also a number of bizarre story elements that would seem ridiculous in most films but are even moreso in such a deadly serious, seemingly naturalistic film. Elizabeth’s teenage daughter is paralysed from the waist down after a bad accident so rides around on her dad’s back for most of the film. Later in the film, a character is randomly injured when a glass seemingly just explodes in his mouth. There might be some point behind these odd events, some significance that I’m not seeing, but it didn’t connect with me at all.
Nor too did much of the acting. Gallacher’s performance should suggest some kind of inner turmoil but the young actor just seems borderline comotose while Henshall gives a performance so weepie and overwrought that you feel he might drown in his own phlegm. Negga’s performance has potential but the film around her doesn’t do her any favours.
For fans of Graham’s previous work, there might be something here to savour. Otherwise, the only real plus is the beautiful scenery.