English math genius, unsung hero of World War II and the father of modern computing, Alan Turing is long overdue a big, glossy Hollywood biopic. Enter The Imitation Game, a largely conventional but stylish and compelling effort from Headhunters director Morten Tyldum.
Benedict Cumberbatch stars as Turing, who is here presented as a typical movie genius: exceptionally intelligent and unerringly rational but often cold, callous and socially awkward. He’s dedicated to his work but has little time for his colleagues; a team handpicked by the military to crack the Enigma code, who are all alienated by Turing’s perceived intellectual superiority. While they work on cracking the Nazi’s code by hand, day by day, in a mission that is essentially impossible, Turing holes away on his own, relentlessly and methodically assembling a machine that will crack the Nazi’s code and save millions of lives.
Of course, Turing’s genius eventually wins over his colleagues and they back his dedication to perfecting his machine, which infuriates Commander Denniston (Charles Dance), the typical short-sighted figure of authority who wants to sack Turing and destroy his machines, despite the potential of the work he’s doing. More accommodating is MI6’s Agent Menzies (Mark Strong) who sees Turing as a valuable asset and a man well-versed in keeping secrets.
Secrets play a big part in The Imitation Game, both in the classified nature of Turing’s work and in his own private life, where his homosexuality was essentially kept a secret until 1952 when he was arrested and prosecuted for a sexual encounter with a young male prostitute. This is where the film begins and ends, and the story of his war time endeavours are told via flashback as he relates his tale to a police offer (Rory Kinnear) who is more interested in Turing’s past than his current crimes.
There are further flashbacks that cover a young Turing’s schooldays and his close friendship with another boy that began to awaken his sexuality. During the war, some of his more astute colleagues sense that Turing isn’t interested in woman but one of them – Joan Clarke (Keira Knightley) – proves to be a kindred spirit and the pair embark on a plutonic relationship that serves both of them well: he gets to appear straight while she gets out of her parents house to do the kind of ‘man’s work’ that they don’t approve of.
Tyldum largely handles the three separate timeframes well and the film smoothly flits between them, with each one helping inform the other. The war section of the film forms the largest portion of the film however and relies on a lot of tropes familiar to the genius biopic subgenre, with the distant Turing achieving incredible professional feats but struggling with personal relationships, infused with a welcome dose of warm humour.
The post-war section deals with the real tragedy of Turing’s life as he accepts chemical castration in favour of jail time as punishment for his homosexuality in order to remain at home and continue his work. If there’s a real issue with the narrative, it’s that these scenes are too brief and disappointingly coy, refusing to delve deep into Turing’s latter days and his eventual suicide, instead favouring the more crowd-pleasing war efforts that, while unquestionably compelling and essential to understanding Turing’s legacy, are a little too conventional.
However, despite the film’s shortcomings, Benedict Cumberbatch soars as Turing, giving a complex and layered performance that lifts the film. He wrings laughs from Turing’s social awkwardness but is never less than believable as the determined and fiercely intelligent genius who changed a world which later persecuted him.
With Cumberbatch’s extraordinary performance at the centre, The Imitation Game is a respectable, entertaining and accessible biopic that gives an overview of Turing without getting into the nitty-gritty of his life.